I'd have to say that Star Trek: Insurrection is the best odd-numbered Star Trek film if you ask me.

I personally disliked Insurrection, of all the movies it certainly was the most boring. Also it was my way of asking which of the bad movies was the best.

The Search for Spock, by far…

Best: the search for spock. Favorite: the final frontier. I think all the odd numbered movies are actually underrated, except for insurrection and the reboot movies.

In order of most favorite to least:

TSfS

Generations

TMP

FF

Insurrection

Star Trek (‘09)

Beyond

The first three on this list I like very much, indeed!

Search for Spock

I never understood why TSFS is considered among the "bad" films.... I think it is just in the unfortunate position of being caught between two great films. It still holds its own...

@Gvsualan are you an admin here on memory alpha? 🤔 Anyways, I completely agree with you. I also think the search for spock is fantastic and legendary, and that it's underrated, but that it probably just gets overshadowed by some of the other more popular movies. I also especially like the final frontier, the voyage home, the undiscovered country, generations and first contact.

@Gvsualan I think search for spock it's the most underrated trek movie.

@Michael Benucci

Yes. I think that's what the little gold star means.