In the 2380s, Clancy supported a firm stance of the Federation towards the Romulan Star Empire in the face of the looming threat of the Romulan supernova. Even before the attack on Mars in 2385, she was concerned about the potential secession of Federation member worlds over the continued Starfleet support of Romulan evacuation efforts, spearheaded by then-admiral Jean-Luc Picard. (PIC: "Maps and Legends")
In 2399, Clancy served as the CNC of Starfleet. That year, she was approached by Picard in her office in San Francisco, who requested a reactivation of his commission to investigate the death of Dahj Asha. Although Clancy soundly denied his request, she still later prompted Commodore Oh with an investigation of Picard's claims about a Romulan infiltration of Starfleet. (PIC: "Maps and Legends")
Some three weeks later, Picard contacted Clancy from La Sirena to report on recent events and request a Starfleet squadron to defend Soji Asha's homeworld from the Zhat Vash. After some tense words, Clancy agreed to send a squadron to rendezvous with him at Deep Space 12. (PIC: "Broken Pieces")
Picard and Clancy did not always see eye-to-eye. Clancy was especially angered by Picard's denouncement of Starfleet and his eventual public resignation following the agency's decision against further support of the Romulan cause in 2385. She also expressed concern that Picard may no longer stay out of the public eye following his blunt interview with FNN in 2399. Despite her resentment of Picard, Clancy still took his concerns seriously enough to start a quiet investigation of his claims, and later agreed to send a squadron to help defend synthetics from the Zhat Vash, telling him to "shut the fuck up" in order to inform him of this. (PIC: "Maps and Legends", "Broken Pieces")
Clancy seemed to have a trusting working relationship with Commodore Oh. Following Picard's reports of a possible Romulan plot against the Federation, Clancy sought Oh's advice on the matter, not realizing the Commodore's own involvement with the Zhat Vash. (PIC: "Maps and Legends")
"The Romulans were our enemies, and we tried to help them for as long as we could, but even before the synthetics attacked Mars, fourteen species within the Federation said 'Cut the Romulans loose, or we'll pull out.' It was a choice between allowing the Federation to implode, or letting the Romulans go."
"The Federation does not get to decide if a species lives or dies."
"Yes we do. We absolutely do. Thousands of other species depend upon us for unity, for cohesion. We didn't have enough ships left. We had to make choices, but the great Captain Picard didn't like his orders."
"I was standing up for the Federation for what it represents! For what it should STILL represent!"
"How dare you lecture me!"
"This is no longer your house, Jean-Luc, so do what you're good at: go home. Request denied."
"That's a hell of a report."
"And you thought I was a desperate old man. Quixotic, paranoid, possibly senile..."
"Let's just leave it at quixotic."
"And now the windmills have turned out to be giants."
Kirsten Clancy was played by Ann Magnuson.
Clancy is seen wearing a five pip admiral's rank, the first time such an insignia has ever been seen on screen. She is the first "prime reality" Starfleet fleet admiral seen on camera since Fleet Admiral Alynna Nechayev and the first CNC seen on camera since Fleet Admiral Shanthi, who appeared in TNG: "Redemption II" and was described as the "head of Starfleet" in that episode's script. Both Nechayev and Shanthi wore the rank insignia of vice admirals.
Fleet Admiral Cartwright and the Commander in chief named "Bill" appeared in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country twenty nine years earlier. Fleet Admiral Marcus of the Kelvin timeline was depicted in Star Trek Into Darkness. A mirror universe fleet admiral (Gardner) was depicted in ENT: "In a Mirror, Darkly, Part II"